Alternatives in Jewish Bioethics by Noam J. Zohar

By Noam J. Zohar

This discussion among the Jewish normative culture and Western ethical philosophy addresses relevant modern matters in clinical ethics.

Alternatives in Jewish Bioethics comprises a discussion among modern, Western ethical philosophy and the Jewish culture of legal/moral discourse (Halakha). spotting that no unmarried culture has a monopoly on legitimate ethical teachings, it seeks to counterpoint our moral views via mutual trade.

This is facilitated by means of a non-authoritarian method of Judaism--a transparent substitute to the implicitly insular, "take-it-or-leave-it" procedure usually encountered during this box. Following within the footsteps of classical rabbinic discussions, normative pronouncements are grounded in purposes, open to severe exam. The "alternatives" are in the e-book as well--the presentation all through avoids one-sided conclusions, bringing up and reading or extra positions to make feel of the talk. those specific arguments also are associated with a bigger photo, contrasting simple topics: non secular naturalism as opposed to spiritual humanism.

Concretely, the ebook addresses the various primary modern concerns within the ethics of drugs. those contain assisted suicide and euthanasia, donor insemination and "surrogate" motherhood, using human cadavers for studying and learn, and allocation of scarce assets at either the person and social degrees.

Show description

Read Online or Download Alternatives in Jewish Bioethics PDF

Similar jewish books

Sources for Ancient History (Sources of History)

If a pupil needs to create an image of a contemporary society in all its facets, there's little of what he must be aware of that he can't understand, even supposing there should still be a lot that he can't comprehend. For the background of Greece and Rome, there's a good deal that's easily unknowable. From the top of the archaic age of Greece, there's an unbroken series of works through Greek and, later, Roman historians right down to the top of antiquity.

Jewish Representation in British Literature 1780-1840: After Shylock (Nineteenth-Century Major Lives and Letters)

Describing Jewish illustration both by Jews and Gentiles within the British Romantic period, Scrivener integrates pop culture with belletristic writing to discover the wildly various remedies of stereotypical figures: the pedlar, the moneylender, the Jew’s daughter, los angeles belle juive, the convert, the prophet, the alchemist, and the felony.

Journeys in holy lands : the evolution of the Abraham Ishmael legends in Islamic exegesis

Students have lengthy pointed to the nice affinity among tales present in the Bible and the Qur'an, but no clarification has been proposed that satisfactorily explains the abnormal mixture of extraordinary likeness and targeted divergence. Firestone presents a fresh, new method of scriptural problems with textuality, exegesis, and the origins and use of legend.

Additional info for Alternatives in Jewish Bioethics

Sample text

The "laws concerning a gasses" begin with the prohibitions regarding hastening the death of a gasses; the following section reads: "A person who is told 'it is now three days since we saw your relative gosses' should observe the rituals of mourning, for that relative has surely died" (YD 339:2). Clearly, a gosses is conceived as a patient who will not live more than three days; he is already dying, and the issue is only just how fast (or how slow) the process will be. This understanding poses a difficult problem for modern application of the medieval "hands-off' norm of respect for the process of dying.

This brings to mind the problems involved in attempts to distinguish, in the modern context, between "ordinary" and "extraordinary" means of sustaining life. Yet for understanding the medieval traditions, it seems essential to emphasize their background of limited medical capability. All these rulings apply only to persons in the condition of gasses, a category which evidently was clearly identifIable. To get a sense of this category, we may refer to R. Joseph Caro's sixteenth century code, the Shulhan 'Arukh.

Neither Ha-Levi nor any con- 48 Alternatives in Jewish Bioethics temporary halakhic writer seems prepared to accept such a sweeping disavowal of human intervention at the end of life. It may, nevertheless, be possible to formulate a more refined Nahmanidean position, although as far as I know. such a refinement has yet to be offered. This would involve redefining the gosses category so as to deSignate-against the backdrop of contemporary medicine-a fmal stage of the dying process. It would be interesting to see such a pOSition worked out in detail; this would have to include, of course, convincing modes of distinguishing the natural process itself from illicit interference.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.43 of 5 – based on 45 votes

Published by admin